PBCentral.com

Home > Columns > Noah Kravitz

by Noah Kravitz, Reviews Editor 25 September 2006


Typing by Backlight: Saitek Eclipse II Illumninated Keyboard



Pros: Multi-Color, Dimmable Backlight; Good Feel to Keys; Solid Construction
Cons: Windows Layout Confusing for Mac Users; Media Keys Don't Work Under OS X; Uncomfortable Wrist Rest
In Sum: Cool Concept But They Need a Mac Version
Pricing: $69.95
More Info: Product Page

Saitek sent us their latest keyboard, the Eclipse II, for review. The Eclipse II is a 104-key USB keyboard featuring a multi-colored, dimmable backlight -- with the Eclipse II plugged into your setup, you can type in the dark and do it with your choice of a purple, red, or blue backlight illuminating the keys. It's pretty cool. Except that it's made for Windows and Saitek hasn't shipped or posted a Mac driver.

When I plugged the Eclipse II into my Mac, OS X recognized it as a new keyboard and guided me through a quick setup process. The Eclipse II was recognized as a standard US-layout keyboard and was immediately ready for use. I quickly noticed two things: 1. The Option and Command keys were reversed. 2. The dedicated media keys didn't exactly work: Six of the eight buttons did nothing at all, and the other two did the wrong things (Stop actually Muted, and Play/Pause acted as Volume Down).

A look at the keyboard confirmed its Windows-centricity by virtue of the little Windows Flag icon on the Command keys. A trip to the Saitek website confirmed my fears that no Mac drivers were available for download. So I went into OS X's Mouse and Keyboard preference pane and did what I could, remapping the Option and Command keys to work as they do on my iBook's built-in keyboard and my usual external keyboard, a Kensington Slim Type Keyboard for Mac. This solved the problems I was having when I tried to cut, paste, save, or Option-Tab my way through applications. Only problem was when I unplugged the Saitek and went back to typing directly on my iBook's keyboard, I had to remap the keys or else face the same problems (in reverse). Uggh.

Also, there was nothing I could find to remap the media keys. And at that point I really didn't feel like going searching around the Web to find a third-party remapping app. I'd seen enough: This was a keyboard build for Windows that made it's way to a Mac-centric website for review. Oh, well.

The keys on the Eclipse II have a nice feel to them, and are comfortable to work with (I typed this review on them, as a matter of fact). They have a longer, noisier action than the slim-profile keyboards favored by some - including the aforementioned Kensington - but it's not bad. The feel is somewhat like a softer, modern version of the old school keyboards that shipped with Apple IIs and the first Macs. The snap-on adjustable wrist rest, however, is another story. It's hard plastic that's not very comfortable on the palms and also a little too slick - as I typed I found myself pushing my hands back "up the keyboard" to counteract their slipping down the wrist rest.

Conclusion
If Saitek wants to reach the Mac market, they'd do well to build a Mac-specific version of the Eclipse II with Option, Command buttons in the places (and with the labels) that Mac users are accustomed to. And to ship it with a Mac driver. And a softer, grippier wrist rest. The dimmable, multi-color backlight is cool, and the keyboard has a nice feel to it. Too bad it so clearly wasn't build to play nice with Macs.

The Saitek Eclipse II Illuminated Keyboard sells for $69.96 direct from the Saitek Online Store. Compare prices at PCPrices/Mac.

* * * *

Get the best price for your new iPod at PCPrices.net/iPod

* * * *
Noah Kravitz is the Reviews Editor for PBCentral. A writer, educator, and musician, he lives in Oakland, CA and is the author of Teaching and Learning with Technology.


 

Week's Best MacBook Prices:
Specials for PowerBook Central Readers

17" MacBook Pro
2.8GHz: MSRP $2499
spacer
ClubMac - The Online Mac SuperStore $2248.99
MacConnection $2249
MacMall - Your #1 Apple Superstore! $2294

15" MacBook Pro
2.53GHz: MSRP $1699
2.66GHz: MSRP $1999
2.8GHz: MSRP $2299

spacer
2.53GHz 2.66GHz 2.8GHz
ClubMac - The Online Mac SuperStore $1578.99 $1798.99 $2088.99
MacConnection $1579 $1799 $2089
MacMall - Your #1 Apple Superstore! $1579 $1844 $2094

13" MacBook Pro
2.26GHz: MSRP $1199
2.53GHz: MSRP $1499
spacer
2.26GHz 2.53GHz
ClubMac - The Online Mac SuperStore $1118.99 $1398.99
MacConnection $1119 $1399
MacMall - Your #1 Apple Superstore! $1094 $1394

MacBook Air
1.86GHz/120GB HD: MSRP $1499
2.13GHz/128GB SSD: MSRP $1799
spacer
1.86GHz 2.13GHz
ClubMac - The Online Mac SuperStore $1438.99 $1728.99
MacConnection $1439 $1729
MacMall - Your #1 Apple Superstore! $1439 $1729

Apple Store
Apple Refurbished
17" 2.93GHz MacBook Pro: $2199
17" 2.66GHz MacBook Pro: $1949
15" 2.93GHz MacBook Pro: $1949
15" 2.66GHz MacBook Pro: $1699
15" 2.8GHz MacBook Pro: $1699
15" 2.4GHz MacBook Pro: $1349
13" 2.4GHz Alum MacBook: $1099
13" 2.0GHz Alum MacBook: $949
13" 2.13GHz White MacBook: NA
13" 1.8GHz/128GB MacBook Air: $1449
13" 1.6GHz/120GB MacBook Air: $1199

Updated Daily


Apple Store

New iMac!  The all-in-one for everyone.


Terms of Use | Privacy | About Us

Copyright © 1996-2007 Pricenet Central All Rights Reserved.