 |
Home > Columns > Noah
Kravitz
Product Review:
DLO HomeDock for iPod, $99.95 - DLO (Digital Life Outfitters) 4 January 2006 by Noah
Kravitz Reviews Editor Your
iPod at Home
The iPod accessory market just grows and grows, and every new
generation of the little gadget that turned Apple's bottom line around
brings with it a slew of new (or slightly renewed) gizmos to extend the
media player's capabilities. While few of these accessories actually
give the iPod new functionality, the best of them let you use it in more places, more easily,
and with better results.
DLO's new HomeDock is one of those accessories. Built to fit most
any full-sized iPod or iPod nano, the HomeDock combines versatility and
simplicity with a sharp design that makes it a winner. If you're
looking for a way to integrate your iPod into your home entertainment
center, particularly if you've got a newer iPod or nano that features
photo and/or video playback, the HomeDock is well worth a look.
DLO sent us a review sample and I've been testing it out for the past couple of months with great results. At first look the hundred dollar price tag seemed a bit steep, but then I considered what it would cost to piece together HomeDock's functionality (line-level a/v out via RCA and S-Video, USB dock, charging dock with AC adaptor, IR remote control) with other accessories from the Apple Store's. I'd need an Apple Universal Dock, $39; USB Power Adaptor, $29; Apple Remote, $29, and; Apple AV Cable, $19. That's $116 so far and I've got four separate devices to deal with and no S-Video out anywhere in the mix. Suddenly, $99.95 for the HomeDock doesn't sound so bad (compare prices at pcprices.net).
Works Good, Looks Great The HomeDock comes with a base module, remote control, six-foot
a/v cable with RCA connectors, six-inch RCA-to-minijack adapter, AC power
adapter, and user's manual. Set up is simple, and HomeDock works exactly as advertised. Music sounds great
run through the dock's stereo RCA-out jacks into my Onkyo receiver and
Energy speakers, my Tivoli Model Two stereo radio, and my Altec Lansing
powered speakers. The line-level audio connections are of the variable
sort, enabling your iPod's volume to be controlled from the included
remote (as opposed to only from your stereo/powered speaker's controls).
Audiophiles will likely be disappointed by this, as it means an audio
signal of slightly lesser quality than a fixed line-level output would
provide. For most people, however, the difference will be both
negligable and offset by having a volume control alongside the other
iPod controls on the remote.
Photos and videos look very good, as well, played through either the
composite (RCA) or S-Video out jacks to my TV set. The USB 2.0 port
lets me sync to my iBook with a standard USB cable, and the included AC
adaptor keeps my iPod charged while its docked. On the one hand I'm
annoyed that Apple no longer includes an AC adaptor with new iPods. On
the other hand I was thrilled to buy a 5G model with 50% more capacity
(and a smaller overall size) than the previous generation iPod. Either
way, it's nice when aftermarket accessories include an AC adaptor as
part of the price tag. In this regard, the HomeDock is quite handy - I''d be
pretty inclined to spend $100 on all of this functionality before I'd drop $29 for an iPod USB power adapter
by itself.
What really makes HomeDock shine, however, is its industrial design.
The dock is nearly twice the size as Apple's (or anyone else's) iPod
docks at 5.75" x 4" x 1" and finished in black and silver instead of the
iPod-standard white (though, oddly, the remote is white with grey buttons). A backlit DLO logo sits in the center of the
dock's front panel: it shines green when your iPod is docked and blue
when the unit is on but no iPod is detected. Being the owner of a black iPod myself, I really
dig HomeDock's look, and it should mesh nicely with most home a/v setups, which
was probably DLO's intent in designing it.
The double-width of the dock
is due to the iPod connector sitting side by side with a recessed holder
for the included remote control. While the whole thing looks pretty cool
when both an iPod and the remote are docked, the point of a remote control
is to use it, well, remotely, so my remote hasn't sat in the dock since
I first set the unit up. This isn't a big deal, but does seem to be a case
of form trumping function to some extent.
DLO hit a home run in designing the iPod connector itself. Where most
"universal" docks combine a recessed dock connector with interchangable plastic trays to
fit iPods of varying thicknesses, HomeDock features a protruding dock connector
combined with a support arm that adjusts fore and aft to accomodate iPods of
all sizes. The clear plastic support arm sits behind the iPod while its docked; you
adjust it forwards or backwards to fit the iPod and then tighten it into place with a
fingerscrew. The design also works with many iPod cases so you don't have to
remove them for docking. It's simple, clever, and works like a charm.
The tiny remote control works quite well, too. It's not the absolute best iPod
remote out there, but it's pretty comprehensive. Controls include On/Off, Volume Up/Down, Play/Pause,
Track Advance, Previous Track, Track Repeat, Fast-Forward, Rewind, Next Playlist, Previous Playlist,
Shuffle Control, Repeat Control, Mute, and Backlight Toggle. The remote operates on IR instead of
RF, so its range is somewhat limited, but it worked just fine from across my living room (just don't
expect it to transmit through walls).
Conclusion and Recommendations
DLO's HomeDock is the best docking system I've seen for integrating an iPod into a home entertainment
setup. The $99 price tag is fair as compared to assembling a comparable solution from different pieces,
but one hundred dollars is still a lot to pay for a way to plug an iPod into a stereo. Still, if you want
a dock with USB and a/v connectors and a remote control, HomeDock is the way to go. New iPod owners in need
of an AC adaptor will appreciate not having to shell out extra for that, as well.
My only hesitation in recommending HomeDock actually has nothing to do with the product itself - so far
as iPod docks go, HomeDock is absolutely top-notch. Before ordering one, though, you might want to consider
a wireless audio transmitter that broadcasts via Bluetooth or FM stereo (the latter, of course, will sacrifice
some audio fidelity). The one thing that neither DLO nor
anyone else has been able to capture in a remote control is the iPod's user interface; it's true that the iPod
itself is its own best remote. DLO's remote is pretty good, but it offers neither the click wheel nor LCD screen
that make iPods so easy to use. As such, if you're looking for the best way to use your iPod with a home stereo
and don't need photo/video-out capabilities, a wireless transmitter is at least worth considering.
The DLO HomeDock sells for $99.99 and is available direct from the DLO
website and through online and brick-and-mortar retailers.
* * *
Get the best price for your new iPod at PCPrices/iPod
font> * * *
* Noah Kravitz is a writer, educator, and musician who lives
in Oakland, CA and is the author of Teaching and
Learning with Technology. You should go buy a copy. Now. It's
awesome.
|
|
Week's Best MacBook Prices:
Specials for PowerBook Central Readers
|

17" MacBook Pro
2.53GHz i5: MSRP $2299

|
|
|
15" MacBook Pro
2.4GHz i5: MSRP $1799 2.53GHz i5: MSRP $1999
2.66GHz i7: MSRP $2199

|
|
|
13" MacBook Pro
2.4GHz: MSRP $1199 2.66GHz: MSRP $1499

|
|
|
MacBook Air
1.86GHz/120GB HD: MSRP $1499
2.13GHz/128GB SSD: MSRP $1799

|
|
|

Apple Refurbished
|
| June 2009 models: |
|
| 17" 2.8GHz MacBook Pro: |
$1869 |
| 15" 2.66GHz MacBook Pro: |
$1529 |
| 13" 2.53GHz MacBook Pro: |
$1189 |
| 13" 2.26GHz MacBook Pro: |
$929 |
| 13" 2.13GHz/128GB MacBook Air: |
$1549 |
| 13" 1.86GHz/120GB MacBook Air: |
$1249 |
| Oct 2009 models: |
|
| 13" 2.26GHz White MacBook: |
$849 |
| March 2009 models: |
|
| 15" 2.93GHz MacBook Pro: |
$1949 |
| Jan 2009 models: |
|
| 17" 2.93GHz MacBook Pro: |
$2199 |
| 17" 2.66GHz MacBook Pro: |
$1949 |
| Oct 2008 models: |
|
| 13" 1.8GHz/128GB MacBook Air: |
$1449 |
| 13" 1.6GHz/120GB MacBook Air: |
$1199 |
|
Updated Daily |
|

|
 |