Mixed Returns on New Apple Products
Last Tuesday's Apple Media Event was greeted with mixed results, if that, from
fans and critics alike. Apple's stock dropped 3.5% the day Steve Jobs unveilied the Intel-based
Mac mini, iPod HiFi speaker system, and Leather iPod Cases, and pundits, bloggers, and other critics had some
kind and some less
than kind words for the three "fun new products." in Cupertino.
The Intel
Mac mini was expected but its $100 price increase over the G4 version wasn't. The iPod HiFi
speaker system was expected, but people seem underwhelmed with its industrial design, price,
and specs. And the $99 leather iPod case? I still haven't found anything good that's been
said about that one.
Yes, the new mini packs an Intel chip inside. Yes, it comes with Front Row and a remote. Yes, it
features other upgrades that could justify the $100 price increase. But
it still costs $100 more than the old one, which might spell the kiss of death to Apple in a few more
of our nation's schools. It's ironic, because nearly every Mac head I know who's around my age
became a Mac head beacuse s/he had Apple IIes and Mac SEs in their classrooms as a child. Much hyped
iBook contracts aside, Apple is seemingly casting aside the Education market in favor of milking
everything it can out of the iPod. iLife '06 is great software that many a teacher (myself included)
would love to use in the classroom. But at 20% more per computer, the Mac mini may no longer be the no-brainer it
was just one year ago in the eyes of many school Tech Directors.
Steve Jobs may have said that Apple "reinvented the home stereo" with the launch of
the iPod HiFi speaker system, but if you believe in specs then someone's lying. From the Apple
Website: Frequency response: 53Hz to 16kHz ± 3 dB. 53-16,000 Hz does not make an audiophile
happy. Not even close. 20-20,000 (full spectrum of human hearing) is a good place to start. Like
I said, specs alone do not speakers make, but so far not so good for the iPod HiFi.
Bloggers and commenters around the web have been much, much harsher on the "audiophile" claims
made by a single box speaker claiming to be stereo and hi-fi and made for playing compressed
audio. David Colker of the LA Times calls it, "maybe the weakest offering from Apple since the woeful Cube computer of 2000." Then there's this: "Also announced today: the iTravel time machine so you can get back to 1985 and find some
D batteries." Ouch.
Hey, that's not me talking, that's these guys.
Dell Dual-Core Laptop
So I was looking at DealNews.com today and saw a deal for a new Dell Inspiron E1505 Laptop featuring
an Intel Duo Dual Core processor, just like the now-shipping MacBook Pro. The deal was for a 15" widescreen
laptop with free printer for $729 after rebate. Whoah.
I clicked over to the Dell site and did some configuring to bring the Inspiron's specs as close as
possible to the entry-level MacBook Pro's: 1.83 GHz processor, 512MB RAM, 80 GB SATA drive, Bluetooth, Dell's best 15" LCD display.
Final cost? $1,332 before rebate, $1,082 after. That's a good $900 less than a similarly equipped
MBP, and you get a free (if likely lousy) printer. Sure the Dell doesn't have MagSafe, but it does
have four USB 2.0 ports (MacBook has two) in addition to one Firewire, a higher resolution screen
(1680 x 1050 vs. 1440 x 900), S-Video out and a Flash Memory reader. Then again, the MacBook Pro is slimmer, lighter, and
has that nifty backlit keyboard. Then there's that whole Windows thing.
I know I'm comparing Apples and Oranges here, and my PC knowledge is pretty woeful, so you tell me:
What am I missing here? Why is Dell's Dual Core laptop more or less half the price of Apple's? I do believe that
OS X is worth more than Windows MCE (or XP), but there's gotta be some other reason the Mac costs 90% more. Industrial
design? Brand name? Important technical specs I'm too ignorant to see?
Write in. Tell me. Why is the Mac so much pricier?
Ms Pac-Man on Your iPod
The folks at the Linux for iPod project have been working hard, and the latest fruit of their labor
is getting MAME to run on the iPod 5G and nano. MAME stands for Multi Arcade Machine Emulator, and it's an
emulation environment built to run virtual versions of many a classic arcade game read from soft ROM
files.
Granted, to legally play Ms Pac Man from a ROM you have to actually own the arcade game itself,
but the mere idea that an iPod can emulate dozens of classic arcade games from my childhood is almost
too good to be true.
Check it out here (project page) and
here (photos).
* * * *
Get the best price for your new Mac at MacPrices.com
* * * *
Noah Kravitz is
the Reviews Editor for PowerBook Central. A writer, educator, and musician, he lives in Oakland, CA and is the
author of Teaching and
Learning with Technology.